This post compares the significance of injuries that happened during minicamps, organized team activities, and other team workouts between the draft and the opening of minicamps. We’ll update this post as the offseason rolls along.
10 – OLB Thomas Davis, Panthers – While Jon Beason is the heart and soul of the Panthers’ defense, Davis is the biggest playmaker in the front seven now that Julius Peppers is on his way out of town. But Davis, who was beginning a comeback from a 2009 ACL injury that sidelined him for the second half of last season, re-tore the ACL in his right knee in an early June practice. The non-contact injury is devastating for the Panthers, who will almost certainly lose Davis for the 2010 season. While Jamar Williams (who was acquired in a trade with Chicago for S Chris Harris) is a starting-quality replacement, he’s not going to provide the dynamic aspects via blitz and in coverage that Davis can at his best. Even worse, after tearing the same ACL twice, Davis must face questions of whether his career will ever return to the trajectory it was on as the ’09 season dawned. All in all, this is a devastating event for both the team and the player.
9 – OT Willie Colon, Steelers – Colon, the Steelers’ starting right tackle who has 50 straight starts, injured an Achilles during a late-June workout and will miss the season. That’s a huge blow for a Steelers team that has a subpar offensive line in general. Colon was a strong suit on that line, providing stability and some ground-game punch. Without Colon, the Steelers will have to immediately rely on rookie Maurkice Pouncey to start inside so that they can shuffle on the outside. Losing a starter in June is tough, but losing your best offensive lineman is almost devastating.
8 – none
7 – FS Marlin Jackson, Eagles – Jackson, a former Colts first-round pick, moved to Philly this offseason after Indy let him go instead of offering him a restricted free agent tender. Jackson’s play wasn’t the problem in Indianapolis; instead, it was a pair of knee injuries that cost him much of the ’08 season and all of the ’09 campaign. The Eagles brought Jackson over and planned to move him from cornerback to free safety, a spot where they weren’t able to adequately replace Brian Dawkins last season. But Jackson suffered a torn right Achilles tendon in an early June minicamp and now looks like he could miss the season. The best case scenario for Jackson is probably the physically unable to perform list, which would cost him the first six games of the season at least. That’s a big blow that now puts a lot of pressure on rookie Nate Allen, who was selected with the Donovan McNabb pick in the second round of April’s draft. Allen now becomes the Eagles’ only chance to make free safety a plus position instead of a problem spot.
6 (con’t) – WR Steve Smith, Panthers – Smith’s broken arm wasn’t a minicamp injury, but we’re including it because it happened during minicamp season. Smith broke his arm in late June playing flag football, and the injury will sideline him through training camp. Smith is due to return before the season opens, but his absence is disturbing on two fronts. First, the Panthers are trying to break in new starter Matt Moore and develop rookie Jimmy Clausen. Smith’s absence will force Moore and Clausen to emerge with a motley crew of receivers. And the Panthers’ lack of receiving talent is the other reason Smith’s injury is scary. Any setback, and Carolina will enter the season with guys like Dwayne Jarrett, Kenny Moore, and Brandon LaFell trying to perform at a starter level. That won’t work, and it would cause the Panthers’ top-flight running game to face eight-man or even nine-man fronts. Smith’s offseason flag-football jones could end up costing Carolina big.
6 – WR Limas Sweed, Steelers – Sweed, a former second-round pick who has been a disappointment thus far for Pittsburgh, injured his left Achilles tendon in a May minicamp and needed surgery. The team subsequently put Sweed on injured reserve, shelving him for the season. For a Steelers team that dealt starting WR Santonio Holmes and needed Sweed (or rookie Emmauel Sanders or someone else) to step up behind Hines Ward and ’09 rookie surprise Mike Wallace, this injury is a blow. Even though Sweed has been inconsistent, he at least provided a downfield threat. But with him gone, Wallace now must become a starting-quality receiver in his second year, and retreads Antwaan Randle El or Arnaz Battle must make more of an offensive impact than they have in years. We believe in Wallace, but the rest of this equation is now even shakier than it was before Sweed’s injury.
6 (con’t) – WR Domenik Hixon, Giants – Hixon suffered a torn ACL in mid-June, and his injury was blamed on how new the Giants’ practice-field FieldTurf was. It’s a big loss. While Hixon didn’t have the potential to have the impact that Sweed did because the Giants have a deep receiving corps, he had carved out a nice niche as the Giants’ No. 4 receiver and designated down-field threat. More importantly, he had emerged as a dangerous return man who handled duties on both kickoffs and punts. With Hixon gone, the Giants will have to search for a new returner, or they’ll have to risk stalwarts like Mario Manningham or Hakeem Nicks on returns to try to replace Hixon’s explosiveness. That’s what makes Hixon’s loss sting for Big Blue.
5 – OTs Jason Smith and Rodger Saffold and OG Mark Setterstrom, Rams – The Rams picked Saffold at the top of the second round this year to become a bookend tackle to ’09 second overall pick Jason Smith as they seek to rebuild a horrible line. Saffold got some OTA work in before he suffered a right knee sprain in early June that shelved him from any further on-field work until training camp. Smith, meanwhile, suffered a fractured toe that ended the offseason early. The Rams said they were sitting Saffold and Smith to be extra cautious, but it’s always troubling when young players who are in prominent roles miss important development time. But those injuries pale in severity to Setterstrom, who suffered a triceps injury in OTAs that quite possibly could sideline him for the season. Setterstrom has talent, but he’s played just 19 games since entering the league in 2006 because of a raft of injuries that’s still sailing along. And the more injuries that pop up on St. Louis’ line, the less likely (or wise) it is for the Rams to start the season with Sam Bradford under center.
5 (con’t) – S Chad Jones, Giants – Jones wasn’t hurt during a minicamp practice, but his late-June auto accident caused a serious leg injury that will certainly shelve him for the 2010 season and could prove to be career-threatening. Thankfully, Jones had already inked his rookie contract, so the third-rounder will have a little money to collect if he can’t make it onto the football field. And he also has baseball as a professional option if football is too trying on his leg. But for the Giants, losing a terrific prospect like Jones at a position that was a huge problem last year, even if the loss is just for 2010, is a blow.
4 -DE Bryan Smith, Jaguars – The Jaguars grabbed Smith, a disappointment as a third-round pick in Philly, off the Rams’ practice squad last September, and he actually emerged a bit and started two games. With Quentin Groves traded, Smith would have had a role as a backup defensive end behind Aaron Kampman and Derrick Harvey, but Smith tore an ACL and will miss the 2010 season. That’s a tough break at a position that has plagued the Jaguars for several years now. The Jaguars have recently added LBs Freddie Keiaho and Teddy Lehman for more depth at outside linebacker, but neither has the promise as a blitzer that Smith (a former defensive end) showed.
4 (con’t) – CB Kevin Thomas, Colts – Thomas, a third-round pick in this year’s draft, had a real shot of finding playing time right away in Indy after the offseason departures of Marlin Jackson and Tim Jennings. But Thomas suffered what is believed to be a season-ending knee injury in a May minicamp that could end his season before it begins. Thomas was slated to add size to a cornerback group that is now undersized, but now the Colts will need Kelvin Hayden to return from injury and need ’09 rookies Jacob Lacey and Jerraud Powers to step up once again.
4 (con’t) – OT Chris Scott, Steelers – Scott, a fifth-round pick in April’s draft, broke his foot in June and will miss at least three months. That means that Scott won’t be available as the regular season opens, and it makes it likely that Scott will start the season on the physically unable to perform list. On its own, this isn’t a huge blow for the Steelers, but losing Scott along with Willie Colon’s injury depletes Pittsburgh’s offensive tackle depth quickly and will likely force Pittsburgh to sign one or even two tackles to add depth.
3 – CB Rod Hood, Titans – Hood, who started in the Super Bowl for the Cardinals in February 2009, bounced around a ton last year before finding a home in Tennessee and actually starting four games late in the season. He was in the mix for a starting spot once again, but a knee injury during offseason workouts (though not in an OTA) likely ended his 2010 season. It’s a blow for Hood, who seemed to have landed with a team that fit his style, and for the Titans, who had massive cornerback problems last year.
3 (con’t) – DE Derrick Morgan, Titans – Tennessee’s first-round pick has struggled with hamstring and calf injuries that have slowed his rookie offseason. The injuries aren’t serious, but development time is vital for any rookie, especially a first-rounder who has a clear path to a starting spot if he delivers.
3 (con’t) – DT Kenny Smith – Smith, a free agent who played for Kansas City last year, suffered a torn Achilles tendon while working out in July hoping for a roster berth. He’ll now miss the 2010 season. It’s hard to see a free agent in his 30s suffer a blow while trying to earn a job once again.
2 – S Orlando Scandrick, Cowboys – Scandrick broke a finger on his left hand, and the break was so severe that Scandrick won’t be able to participate in any on-field activities until training camp begins because he can’t safely get his hand on the ball. Still, he should be good to begin the season.
2 (con’t) – OT Ed Wang, Bills – Wang, the Bills’ fifth-round pick in the ’10 draft, suffered a high ankle sprain in early June that should shelve him for the rest of the offseason. Wang, who has a chance to back up Demetrius Bell at the crucial left tackle position, needs to provide depth for a Bills team that struggled on the line last year. But this usually persistent injury will limit Wang’s ability to contribute right off the bat.
1 – MLB Stewart Bradley, Eagles – Bradley, who missed all of last season after a training-camp Achilles injury, suffered a calf injury in June workouts that sent him to the bench. The injury wasn’t believed to be serious, but the setback in Bradley’s comeback is worth noting.