Trent Edwards completed a remarkably swift fall from grace Monday when the Bills released him. Edwards, who started the first two games of the season for the Bills, is a former third-round draft pick who started 32 games over the past three-plus years for Buffalo. He showed promise in his first two seasons, but his struggles last year caused him to be benched, and this season new head coach Chan Gailey quickly pulled the plug on Edwards. Ryan Fitzpatrick took Edwards’s starting job last week, and now Edwards is without a job completely. Edwards is a big quarterback with a decent arm, and he’s a smart quarterback as well. But he’s never been able to take advantage of deep threat Lee Evans, and the Bills’ offense has lacked passing-game pop. The Bills reportedly turned down offers for Edwards in the offseason, and given the way things have turned out, that was a mistake, because getting even a late-round draft pick for a player who ended up being cut in September would have been a better resolution than this. Edwards is probably better suited as a backup than a starter, but a change of scenery could help. Edwards wasn’t the long-term answer at quarterback in Buffalo, but his absence shows once again that the Bills haven’t been able to find a quarterback of the future since the Jim Kelly era.
Tag Archives: jim kelly
My brother Kam sent me an interesting link this week that tried to argue that Brett Favre is even better than we think. Basically, this blogger argues that Brett Favre’s career interception percentage of 3.3 percent is much better than most of the QBs in the Hall of Fame — thus undercutting the big argument against Favre as an all-time great.
It’s an interesting theory, but as my brother and I discussed it, we quickly came to the conclusion that there’s an era gap here that the blogger tried to gloss over. Current-era Hall of Famers Troy Aikman, Dan Marino, John Elway, Joe Montana, and Steve Young are all below Favre in terms of interception percentage. Only Warren Moon and Jim Kelly (both of whom started in the NFL about five years before Favre) are above him in this stat.
And as we look at the career passer rating list, this change in eras bears out. Favre is just 18th on this list, behind many the great QBs of the eras in which he’s played — Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Steve Young, Joe Montana, Drew Brees, and Dan Marino. Meanwhile, the only QB from before the Bill Walsh era in the top 20 is Otto Graham, who is an all-time great who always seems to get lost in the discussion.
So while the interception stat doesn’t tell us much about Favre in the end, it does indicate how much the game changed when Bill Walsh came on the scene as a head coach around 1980. (We’d say that the Walsh era began with the Niners’ first Super Bowl win in the 1981 season.)
Kam said this in the discussion…
Most people think of interception stats vis-a-vis the TD to interception ratio. nteresting here to consider it as pass attempts to interception, although I wonder what Favre’s completion rate in general is compared to other QBs with comparable yardage and TDs. You’re right that completion rate and TD-interception ratio would be skewed now in the post West-coast era. Fewer and fewer QBs who can actually throw the ball down the field.
*Troy Aikman (this one is close, because Aikman never piled up monster numbers, but the three Super Bowls vs. one makes the difference)