Each season, we use our Football Relativity tool to compare the impact and importance of suspensions around the NFL. We covered preseason suspensions in this post; now, it’s time to look at in-season suspensions. We compare them using our Football Relativity tool, in which 10 signifies the most damaging suspensions and 1 the least damaging. We’ll update this post throughout the 2011 regular season.
Bengals RB Cedric Benson, via bengals.com
10 – DT Ndamukong Suh, Lions (2 games for stomping a Packers player in Week 12) – On Thanksgiving Day, Suh’s temper got the best of him as he stomped Packers OG Evan Dietrich-Smith. That led to a two-game suspension for the star defensive tackle, right in the midst of Detroit’s playoff push. It was a stiff punishment for on-field action, but Suh’s growing litany of over-aggressive or dirty play made the suspension necessary.
9 – OLB James Harrison, Steelers (1 game for helmet-to-helmet hit) – Harrison has often run afoul of the league’s player-safety initiatives, and when he lowered a head-to-head hit on Browns QB Colt McCoy in Week 13, his past misdeeds caught up to him. So Harrison was suspended for Pittsburgh’s Week 14 game in San Francisco, a 20-3 Steelers lost.
8 – OT Trent Williams and TE Fred Davis, Redskins (4 games each for violating the league’s substance-abuse policy) – Two of the Redskins’ best four players sat out the final four games of the season after failing a post-lockout drug test. The fact that they got an extra strike under the substance-abuse policy and still got caught is a bad sign for Washington in 2012 and beyond, but by the time the suspensions came down, the season was already a lost cause for the Redskins. In that sense, it’s a break for Washington to get these suspensions out of the way so that both players can start 2012 fresh – if they behave.
7 – RB Cedric Benson, Bengals (1 game for violating the league’s personal conduct policy) – Originally, the league levied a three-game suspension on Benson, but on appeal it was reduced to one game plus a one-game-check fine. Benson, the Bengals’ lead running back, had two misdemeanor assault cases during the 2011 offseason. It’s a blow to the Bengals, who rely heavily on Benson and who won’t have him in Week Eight at the Seahawks. But the loss is not nearly as big as it could have been.
6 – Vikings CB Chris Cook (2 games by team) – Cook was suspended by the Vikings for Weeks 7 and 8 after a domestic assualt felony charge. Cook, who has had legal problems before, started getting paychecks again in Week 9, but the team excused him from practice and games while the charge was resolved. That’s a strong tactic to take with the former second-round pick.
5 – none
4 – Giants DT Jimmy Kennedy (4 games for violating the league’s performance-enhancing substance policy) – Kennedy signed with the Giants in August to add depth at a banged-up position, and through the first four games of the season he did pretty well with that. But this suspension (which the Giants reportedly knew was possible when they signed him) takes Kennedy out of the lineup for four games starting in Week 6.
4 (con’t) Rams WR Austin Pettis (4 games for violating league’s performance-enhancing substances policy) – Pettis was suspended for the last two games of 2011 and the first two games of 2012 for violating the league’s PED policy. Pettis had 27 catches in his rookie season, and missing two games of 2012 makes this suspension a little harder to take.
3 – Dolphins CB Vontae Davis (1 game by team) – Davis was suspended for Week 9 after reportedly showing up to practice hung over, although the Dolphins didn’t officially release the reason for the benching.
3 (con’t) – Seahawks OG John Moffitt (4 games for violating the league’s performance-enhancing substances policy) – Moffitt, who started nine games at right guard as a rookie before going on injured reserve, was suspended for four games during his recovery. Moffitt is a key player, but the suspension only cost him money, not playing time. Still, it puts him on notice for future infractions.
2 – Colts OG Jaimie Thomas (4 games for violating the league’s performance-enhancing substances policy) – Thomas is on injured reserve, so this suspension doesn’t impact the Colts much. But it does cost Thomas four game checks. Thomas played in eight games in 2010.
1 – S Brandon Underwood (2 games for violating the league’s personal-conduct policy) – The ex-Packer was given a two-game suspension even though he wasn’t on an NFL roster. So Underwood didn’t lose any money, but he hasn’t found a job since the suspension ended either.