Daily Archives: October 11, 2010

Fantasy Football Applaud or a Fraud Week 5

Which fantasy football standouts from Week 5 do you need to trust, and which performances should you write off as flukes? Each week we answer these questions by going through these performances and deciding whether to applaud or whether it’s a fraud. As always, with each verdict, we’ll give context for what it means.

Donovan McNabb against the Packers. Via espn.com

Quarterbacks

Donovan McNabb, Redskins – McNabb threw for 357 yards against the Packers, but it came with just one touchdown. McNabb has put up good yardage numbers, but his lack of touchdowns keeps him from being a top-12 quarterback for fantasy purposes – especially once bye weeks finish. He’s a spot starter, nothing more. Verdict: A fraud

Running backs

Michael Bush, Raiders – With Darren McFadden sidelined, Bush ran for 104 yards and a touchdown against the Chargers, and added 31 yards for good measure. It goes to show that Bush is talented. However, McFadden’s early-season success means that Bush isn’t simply going to take over the job. Fantasy players need to watch the situation to see how it plays out. Verdict: A fraud

Jamaal Charles, Chiefs – We discussed why Charles is the only Chief you should be starting in our Chiefs/Colts post. Verdict: Applaud

Mike Hart, Colts – We covered Hart in our Chiefs/Colts post and shared how he could be an option for your lineup next week. Verdict: Applaud

Brandon Jackson, Packers – Jackson ran for 110 yards and had 25 receiving yards against the Redskins, but a 71-yard run accounted for more than half of his production. Jackson simply isn’t a special back, which means his fantasy value comes from his exceptional opportunity in Green Bay with Ryan Grant out. That means Jackson is a flex play but nothing more. If you blew your waivers budget grabbing Jackson, you need to be making other plans. Verdict: A fraud

Felix Jones, Cowboys – Jones had 109 rushing yards against the Titans, marking his first breakout game of the season. He also had 15 carries, while Marion Barber had six and Tashard Choice none. We’re not ready to mark this as Jones’ ascension to a fantasy starter, but it’s worth watching. Verdict: A fraud

Malcom Floyd against the Raiders. From espn.com

Wide receivers

Danny Amendola, Rams – Amendola had 12 catches for 95 yards against the Lions, and more importantly, Mark Clayton was injured, leaving Amendola as the Rams’ best receiving option. That makes Amendola worth a roster spot in 12-team leagues. Consider claiming him this week. Verdict: Applaud

Dwayne Bowe, Chiefs – We covered Bowe in our Chiefs/Colts post and shared why you shouldn’t start him. Verdict: A fraud

Michael Crabtree, 49ers – Crabtree has had a disappointing season, but he looked like a No. 1 receiver in the making against the Eagles. That’s a first sign of progress for Crabtree this season, and a hopeful sign for fantasy owners who have been waiting on him to deliver. Verdict: Applaud

Malcom Floyd, ChargersFloyd broke the two-century mark with eight catches for 213 yards and a touchdown against the Raiders. With Vincent Jackson’s holdout looking like a long-term issue, Floyd is undoubtedly the Chargers’ No. 1 wideout, and he should end up as a top 20 fantasy receiver. That means Floyd’s a fantasy starter. Verdict: Applaud

Stevie Johnson, Bills – Johnson had two touchdowns against the Jaguars, and he’s established himself as the Bills’ No. 2 receiving threat. He’s worth picking up in larger leagues, but the Bills’ overall struggles mean that Johnson doesn’t have a ton of value in normal-sized leagues. Remember that Lee Evans, the No. 1 wideout in Buffalo, isn’t really worth starting in most leagues before you pull the trigger on adding Johnson. Johnson’s a talent, but his situation isn’t great. Verdict: A fraud

Brandon Lloyd, Broncos – Lloyd had another huge game against the Ravens with 135 receiving yards and two touchdowns. He’s never produced at this level before, but at this point fantasy owners absolutely must start him every week. Verdict: Applaud

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under Applaud/A Fraud, Fantasy Football, Football Relativity

Rise/Sink/Float Week 5

Each week, we preview teams that are moving up and moving down in our weekly Football Relativity comparison. We’ll analyze all 32 teams on Tuesday. We’re going southern style this week, focusing on teams from the AFC and NFC South divisions.

Earnest Graham leaps for a TD against the Bengals. From espn.com

Rise – Tampa Bay Buccaneers – The Buccaneers moved to 3-1 with a huge 24-21 road win against the Bengals. Late interceptions by Aqib Talib and Sabby Piscitelli led to 10 fourth-quarter points as Josh Freeman once again led a huge comeback for the win. Tampa has a lot of young talent, and that talent is learning to win. They may yet be factors in the NFC South.

Sink – Houston Texans – The Texans blew their second-straight home game in a blowout 34-10 loss to the Giants. They fell behind early and had no chance of stopping the Giants’ passing game. Houston is 3-2, but losing home games to the Giants and the Cowboys isn’t a good sign that they’ll be contenders over the long haul.

Float – Jacksonville Jaguars – The Jaguars got a 36-26 road win at Buffalo to move to 3-2, but a win against the Bills isn’t a great statement about the Jaguars’ talent. Jacksonville has been tough at home, and getting a road win aids any playoff hopes. But we’ll have to see it against a team that’s not a bottom-feeder before we believe it.

2 Comments

Filed under Football Relativity, Rise/Sink/Float