As we continue our fantasy football preparation for 2010, we’re going to analyze players with new teams and predict whether their 2010 numbers will rise above, sink below, or float alongside their 2009 production. In this post, we cover running backs. We covered quarterbacks and running backs and wide receivers in previous posts.
Ben Watson, Browns – Watson has always been a frustration to fantasy owners, because his role in New England fluctuated so widely. He’s averaged four touchdowns per year over the past five seasons, which makes him fantasy relevant, but his inconsistent game splits made him a roll of the dice. The same is true in Cleveland, only now Watson is playing with a worse offense and a worse quarterback. That makes Watson a borderline fantasy backup at a position where most owners keep just one player. Watson will be worth a look as a bye-week fill-in, but he’s not draftable except in the largest leagues. Verdict: Sink
Tony Scheffler, Lions – Scheffler has been a fantasy owner’s fantasy because of his pass-catching prowess, but he’s never broken into the top 10 at the position. Now he moves to Detroit, where he’ll be a compatriot to Brandon Pettigrew at tight end. Scheffler will still get some chances, but the fact that he’s a second tight end puts a cap on the upside he had in Denver. Scheffler is now a bye-week fill-in, not a draftable player. Verdict: Sink
Alge Crumpler, Patriots – Crumpler hasn’t been fantasy relevant since he left Atlanta following the 2007 season, and chances are that he won’t find a huge role in New England either. But it’s worth noting that Crumpler is the only veteran tight end the Patriots have, so if rookies Rob Gronkowski and Aaron Hernandez struggle, Crumpler could provide an under-the-radar contribution for owners desperate for tight-end help. He’s outside the top 25 at the position, but Alge is someone worth at least noticing. Verdict: Rise
Chris Baker of the Seahawks and Alex Smith of the Browns are not fantasy relevant in their new homes, just as they weren’t fantasy relevant last season.