Fantasy Football Applaud or a Fraud – Week 13

Each week, we dive into the stat sheets to see which weekly performers fantasy owners should applaud and which fantasy owners should write off as frauds. You can read past applaud or a fraud analyses in the category listing. And you can also check out our fantasy football thoughts during the week via our Twitter feed here on the blog or here.

Quarterbacks

Jason Campbell, Redskins – Campbell had a huge game against New Orleans, throwing for 373 yards and three touchdowns in a performance that deserved a win. It was good enough to help fantasy owners win, which is consistent with Campbell’s performances of recent weeks. He’s a top 15 fantasy quarterback at this point, and if you have an injured quarterback he’s a terrific fallback option. Verdict: Applaud

Josh Freeman, Buccaneers – Freeman marched the ball up and down the field, throwing for 321 yards against the Panthers, but his five interceptions (three in the red zone) were killers. You simply can’t trust Freeman yet as a fantasy quarterback. Verdict: A fraud

Bruce Gradkowksi, Raiders – In one of the day’s stunners, the Raiders went into Pittsburgh and won thanks to Gradkowski, who threw for 308 yards and three touchdowns. Gradkowski has done a nice job since entering the lineup, and his presence has made other Raiders (especially Zach Miller) fantasy relevant. But Gradkowski is not more than a backup for most fantasy leagues. Unless you’re in a league that starts two quarterbacks, stay away. Verdict: A fraud

Chad Henne, Dolphins – Henne had a huge effort (335 yards, two touchdowns) in the Dolphins’ come-from-behind victory over New England. But that doesn’t mean you can consider starting Henne in the playoffs in your league. He’s a decent enough backup, but not a starter. Still, if you’re in a keeper league, grabbing Henne at this point could prove productive. Otherwise, it’s a moot point. Verdict: A fraud

Brady Quinn, Browns – Quinn threw for three touchdowns against the Browns without an interception, finishing with 271 passing yards. Who knows what Eric Mangini will do with Quinn next year, but Quinn is starting to show that he does have the stuff to be a productive NFL starter. Maybe that happens in Cleveland, or maybe Mangini sets Quinn free. Either way, he’s worth a speculative claim in keeper leagues. But there are other options – Alex Smith, Jason Campbell – who are better bets to produce in fantasy lineups over the remainder of this year. Verdict: Applaud

Alex Smith, 49ers – Even though the Niners lost in Seattle, Smith starred with 310 passing yards and two touchdowns. He’s been productive since entering the lineup, and that makes him about as good a fill-in option as you’re likely to find now. If you end up having to start Smith, he won’t kill you. At this point in the season, that’s a plus. Verdict: Applaud

Running Backs

Joseph Addai, Colts – Addai had two rushing touchdowns against the Titans, and he finally appears to have steered clear of competition from Donald Brown and others in the Colts backfield. For the first time this season, it’s now safe to consider Addai among the top 20 fantasy running backs and a regular starter in normal-sized leagues. Verdict: Applaud

Correll Buckhalter, Broncos – Buckhalter only had 12 carries against the Chiefs, but he produced 113 rushing yards in the game. That reminds owners that Buckhalter has been a nice yardage producer throughout the season. But it was Knowshon Moreno, not Buckhalter, who got in the end zone twice for Denver. That limits Buckhalter’s value and keeps him outside the top 25 of fantasy running backs. Verdict: A fraud

Jerome Harrison, Browns – Harrison had 60 rushing yards and 47 receiving yards against the Chargers, and he caught two touchdown passes. That shows us that he’s the best option in Cleveland’s backfield right now. But that’s damning with faint praise. Harrison isn’t a starting option except for desperate fantasy owners, and if you’re that desperate your playoff hopes were probably done for anyway. Verdict: A fraud

Jonathan Stewart, Panthers – Stewart had a career-high 120 rushing yards and a touchdown, but remember that DeAngelo Williams missed this game due to injury. Once Williams returns, Stewart returns to a guy who’s a consideration for flex spots but not a starting fantasy back. This verdict is for Stewart as a top-20 fantasy back. Verdict: A fraud

Wide Receivers

Davone Bess, Dolphins – Bess, who was Miami’s leading receiver entering this game, went crazy with 10 catches for 117 yards and a score. If you’re desperate for a receiver, Bess is an option, but he’s still not going to produce enough numbers to be a top-40 fantasy wideout. Verdict: A fraud

Antonio Bryant, Buccaneers – Bryant has been banged up most of the year, but he showed up big for Tampa Bay against the Panthers with five catches for 116 yards. He can provide a nice spark for fantasy owners down the stretch. Remember just how productive Bryant was at the end of last season? He may be headed for another December to remember. Verdict: Applaud

Pierre Garcon, Colts – Garcon had six catches for 136 yards against the Titans, marking his sixth game with at least 50 yards receiving. while there’s still some risk in starting him, Garcon is regularly rewarding fantasy owners to the point that he should now be considered a flex option and among the top 25 fantasy wideouts. Verdict: Applaud

Santonio Holmes, Steelers – Holmes has had at least six catches and at least 74 yards in five straight games, and Sunday against the Raiders he had eight catches for 149 yards and a score. There’s no excuse not to have Holmes in your lineup every week. Verdict: Applaud

Robert Meachem, Saints – Another week, another touchdown for Meachem, who has now scored in five straight games. And he did that Sunday against the Redskins not just with a fumble recovery for a touchdown but with a monster receiving game with eight catches for 142 yards and a second score. If you’re not starting Meachem at this point, it’s your fault. Verdict: Applaud

Louis Murphy, Raiders – The Raiders went crazy throwing the ball in Pittsburgh, and Murphy was a beneficiary with 128 yards and two scores on just four catches. While Murphy isn’t an automatic start, he’s probably the best receiver Oakland has at this point, and Bruce Gradkowski is a competent quarterback. That means Murphy is a pickup who could serve as a sleeper or an injury fill-in down the stretch. Verdict: Applaud

Devin Thomas, Redskins – Thomas has gone without a catch in five of the games he’s played in this year, but he’s now had multiple catches in four straight games, including a breakout performance with seven catches for 100 yards and two scores against the Saints. That’s worth noting in keeper leagues, because the second-year player is around the career path in which receivers often start to get it. But it would be foolish to expect Thomas to be a fantasy contributor the rest of this year. Verdict: A fraud

Roddy White, Falcons – If White can put up 104 yards and a touchdown with Chris Redman throwing the ball against an Eagles team that’s strong and deep at cornerback, then you can trust him as a starter going forward no matter how long Matt Ryan remains out. Verdict: Applaud

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under Applaud/A Fraud, Fantasy Football, Football Relativity

One response to “Fantasy Football Applaud or a Fraud – Week 13

  1. chase

    thanks for your meachem advice last week. he may have just catapulted me into the second round of the playoffs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s